|
. .

?

: . . 16. , 2013. . 310.

.3 . XIX (326333) :


,
, , !
,
, ,
, [] ;
, ,
:
, 1.

(XXIV. 465467), , . , , , :


, , ;
, ,
, .

. (IV. 39) , :


,
.

,
, ;
,
, , 2.

XI (506537) : , , - .

, . , .4 ; : , , , , .

( Did/A). , 327: εἴ που ἔτι ζώει γε <Νεοπτόλεμος θεοειδεής>καὶ Ἀριστοφάνης προηθέτει τὸν στίχον, ὥς φησι Καλλίστρατος· τό τε γὰρ ἐπὶ παιδὸς κομιδῇ λέγεσθαι διστακτικῶς εἴ που ἔτι ζώει, καὶ ταῦτα μηδὲ πόρρω τῆς Σκύρου κειμένης, ὕποπτον, τό τε θεοειδής ἀκαίρως προσέριπται (Schol. Did. T 327 a. Erbse. T. IV. P. 636).

, , : , , ; θεοειδεής . . . , , , , , 3. , , 4.

, , . 327 , , τόν πυθοίμην5. , , 325, (326327 ), ()6.

.5 , 7. . , , . , . , , 8. , , XIX   , XIV. 466467 , - 9, , . , . 10. , , , . , , , (IX. 144147):


:
, , .
[], , ,

(IX. 388, 393394):


;
<>
,
  .

, , . , , - , , , . , , , (I. 396406; XVI. 220224, 574576; XVIII. 5460, 331332; XIX. 422423). , . , , . , ,   11, -   .6 . , . . , , .

1. IX (IX. 667668) , . (T. Ι. 668 ab T. Ω. 765: Erbse. T. II. S. 538; T. V. S. 639) (A. 6263: Valk. T. I. P. 76; I. 666668: Valk. T. II. P. 833) , 12.

2. XXII , , ; , , , , - (6671). , , (Paus. X. 27). , , : .

3. XXIV , , (765766). , , , , , , (Ep. II. 18); . . , , , , : , , : (II. 303329). .7 , , , (II. 171176), . , , (XVII. 326327). (XXIV. 321322). , 13. , -   , . , , - : , , . . : , , , . , , . ; . , , . , , , ; .

, , , , , , , (Procl. Chrest. 1).

, , ( , 14). , . , . . (IV. 39) . , , , ( ). .8 , ( , ). , , . , 15.

, , .

, . . , , . . 16. , , , , , - , , , . : , , , , , , . . , , ? . ୸ , , , , , .

, , ,   , , . , , :

1. , , (Paus. X. 27. 2).

2. , , (Paus. X. 27. 1).

3. , , (Paus. X. 27. 2).

4. , , 17,   (Procl. Chrest. 4).

5. (Paus. X. 26. 4).

.9 6. , , (Procl. Chrest. 2).

7. , , ,   (Paus. X. 27. 1).

8. (Paus. X. 27. 1).

9. , , 18, 19, 20 (EGF. 27; PEG. 34).

10. , (Paus. X. 27. 2) (Procl. Chrest. 4), .

11. , , (Paus. X. 27. 1).

12. (Paus. X. 26. 4).

13. , (Paus. X. 26. 1) (Procl. Chrest. 4), .

,   . , , 21: . , ,     . . : , , 22. .10 , ; : , . , , , .

, . , . , , , . , .

Khimin M. N. Did Homer know The Tale of Neoptolemos?

There is one passage in the Iliad, mentioning Neoptolemos (XIX. 326327). However some authors, including Martin L. West, consider it to be a late insertion and suppose that Homer was not aware of the story about this hero. But an analysis of a few other passages from the epic (IX. 667668, XXII. 6671, XXIV. 764767) allows us to make the opposite conclusion: tradition about Neoptolemos indeed appeared before the Iliad.


  • 1 . . .
  • 2 . . .
  • 3Van Der Valk M. Researches on the Text and Scholia of the Iliad. Part. 2. Leiden, 1963. P. 404. , , (XIX. 334337).
  • 4Edwards M. W. The Iliad: A Commentary. Cambr., 1991. Vol. V: books 1720. P. 273.
  • 5Bolling G. M. The Athetized Lines of the Iliad. Baltimore, 1944. P. 164; Huys M. Euripides, Alexandros fr. 46 Snell Unmasked as Ilias T. 325329 // ZPE. 1989. Bd. 79. P. 264265; West M. L. Toward a chronology of early Greek epic // Relative Chronology in Early Greek Epic Poetry. Cambr., 2012. P. 238.
  • 6οὐ μὲν γάρ τι κακώτερον ἄλλο πάθοιμι, || οὐδ᾿ εἴ κεν τοῦ πατρὸς ἀποφθιμένοιο πυθοίμην, || ὅς που νῦν Φθίηφι τέρεν κατὰ δάκρυον εἴβει || χήτεϊ τοιοῦδ᾿ υἷος· ὃ δ᾿ ἀλλοδαπῷ ἐνὶ δήμῷ || εἵνεκα ῥιγεδανῆς Ἑλένης Τρωσὶν πολεμίζω || ἠὲ τὸν ὃς Σκύρῳ μοι ἔνι τρέφεται φίλος υἱός, || εἴ που ἔτι ζώει γε Νεοπτόλεμος θεοειδής (321327).
  • 7Forsdyke J. Greece before Homer. Ancient chronology and mythology. N. Y., 1957. P. 110111; West M. L. Iliad and Aethiopis // CQ. 2003. Vol. 53. No. 1. P. 9; Cameron A. Young Achilles in the Roman World // JRS. 2009. Vol. 99. P. 21.
  • 8Kullmann W. Ilias und Aithiopis // Hermes. 2005. Bd. 133. Ht. 1. S. 13.
  • 9Homers Ilias. Gesamtkommentar. B., 2006. Bd. VI. Gesang 19. Faszikel 2: Kommentar. S. 141.
  • 10Forsdyke J. Op. cit. P. 111.
  • 11 . .  // . ., 2012. . 11. . 249256.
  • 12 , , , , IX. 667668 (Hainsworth B. The Iliad: A Commentary. Cambr., 1993. Vol. III: books 912. P. 145146). . , , , , (Cameron A. Op. cit. P. 21). , , . : , ( ) ; , ( . .  // Studia historica. 2011. . XI. . 627).
  • 13Breslove D. How Old Were Achilles and Neoptolemus? // CJ. 1943. Vol. 39. No. 3. P. 160161; Kullmann W. The relative chronology of the Homeric Catalogue of Ships and of the lists of heroes and cities within the Catalogue // Relative Chronology in Early Greek Epic Poetry. Cambr., 2012. P. 212214.
  • 14Edwards M. W. Op. cit. P. 273.
  • 15 , (2030 ) .
  • 16Hedreen G. Capturing Troy. The Narrative Functions of Landscape in Archaic and Early Classical Greek Art. Ann Arbor, 2004. P. 114115.
  • 17Gantz T. Greek Myth. A Guide to Literary and Artistic Sources. Baltimore; L., 1993. Vol. 2. P. 650.
  • 18, , , , , . , , , , , .
  • 19 VI . . . , , . . (Hedreen G. Capturing Troy. The Narrative Functions of Landscape in Archaic and Classical Greek Art. Ann Arbor, 2001. P. 133. Note 40). , . , . , . , , , , (Robertson M. Troilos and Polyxene: Notes on a Changing legend // Eumousia: Ceramic and Iconographic Studies in Honour of Alexander Cambitoglou. Sydney, 1990. Vol. 1. P. 6364).
  • 20 , .
  • 21, , , , .
  • 22West M. L. Op. cit. P. 9.
  • 1271868541 1271865563 1288635317 1472737928 1472739881 1472740512

    , .