| | |
. .


2923 . . .
*

Studia historica. . 13. 2013. . 158177.

.158 23 .1 . , 20- . , , . , , , , 2, , 3: , , , 4, , , 5.

, , 6, : .159 , 7.

, , , , .-. . 8. , , , , 23 . , , , .

. 9 , , , . 2723 . , . , 23 ., . , . 20- ., .

. , , , 10. , , , . .160 , auctoritas, .

, . 30 23 . (Dio Cass. LI. ind.; LIII. ind.). 27 . , . , , , , , (Dio Cass. LIII. 12)11. 27 . , , 25 .  . , 23 . , 12.

. auctoritas, (RGDA. 34). 20- .   , , , , .13 , auctoritas . 20- .

29 . , (Suet. Tib. 6). 14; .161 , , , , 15. : (Nic. Dam. FGH. 127. 17)16. (Dio Cass. LI. 21. 3)17. , , . 2625 . 18 , (Dio Cass. LIII. 26. 1). , , . , , (Nic. Dam. FGH. 127. 2122; Suet. Aug. 8. 2; Dio Cass. XLV. 3. 1). , 19. , . : 46 . (Nic. Dam. FGH. 127. 19).

25 . ,   . - , 20 (Suet. Aug. 63; Dio Cass. LIII. 27. 5). 24 . 18- , , (Plin. NH. XIX. 6. 24; Tac. Ann. I. 3. 1; Dio Cass. LIII. 28. 3). , (Nic. Dam. FGH. 127. 8; App. BC. III. 9 .)21. (Dio Cass. LIII. 28. 3). , .162 20 , . , .

29 23 ., :

24 . , 22;

: 23, , ;

: ; ; , . , ,  .   , ;

, , auctoritas . 20- . , .

, , 23 . . , , .

, , 20- . . .

, , (Vell. Pat. II. 93. 1; Sen. Consol. ad Polyb. 15. 3; Tac. Ann. I. 3. 1; Hist. I. 15. 1; Dio Cass. LIII. 30. 2; 31. 23)24, , . , , .163 25. . , (I. 12), 25 .26 , .

, : , . , , (LIII. 31. 2) (II. 93. 1), , , . , . , .

, , ; 27. , , . 29 . . 13 , . , , , . , , .

.164 , . , , , (LIII. 27. 5) , (I. 12. 45) 28. . . , , : , , . , ; 29. , , : , 45- , 츭 , . , . , , , , , (Dio Cass. LIV. 6. 45), , c 30.

. , , , , , . , 25 . - , , , , ( 28 .) 31. , , , , .165 32. , , , , ; , .

. , 33. , , , ,   , 34.

35, . , . .

, , . , , , . , . ୸, , 21 . , , 36. .166 , , 37.

. : (domus Iuliorum Claudiorumque)38. , , - , . , , 39. : 40.

, 24 ., , , ( , ), 26 , 16 . , 24 . , 41. . , , , , (Dio Cass. XLVIII. 34. 45). 28 . , , (RGDA. 34. 1; Tac. Ann. III. 28. 3; Dio Cass. LIII. 2. 5)42. , , 43, . , .167 , .

. , 23 . , , 44. . , , . , . , , , , . , , 23 . , . , , , (   ) , ; .

. , , , , . , , , . 45.

, , . . 25- . , . . ,   46. . , Roman Provincial Coinage, , 47. . , , : , , , ; ୸ . (tentatively) .168 , . , , 48. , . , , 49; , , : , , 50. . , 51. 52, , , , , 53. . ; Roman Provincial Coinage (reasonable). , , 17- . , : 2120 . ( 29 . ), 19 . , 54. 2523 . , 20 . , .169 20 55, , .

, . .

, . , . -, , , (ILS. 898); , (.  MC745). , 56.



-, , , , , ୸ (, .  Ma 1207); (.  Ma 3547)57.

, , ; , , -, ( ), . , , - 58.

, , , , . ( , , , .170 ), , , , . . , ୸, ( )59; , , .

, , . , , , , , , , . , ( ) . : . 23 . , , 60. , , , - .

,   , . (. . 7) . 23 . . , , . ,   . , 61. , , , . , . , : 62; , , - , .171 . , 15 , . , , , .

, , , , , , , , .

, , 63, 23 . , , 64 , , 65. , , 28 . , . . 23 . . , , , 23 .

23 . ; . , - .172 (Fasti Cap. ad ann. 730)66, . . . 67, ; , , (Tac. Ann. II. 43. 2). , , 68.

, . , , , ,   (Suet. Aug. 28. 1; Dio Cass. LIII. 30. 12). , , , (Dio Cass. LIII. 30. 2), , , , , . , ,   , 69, , 70.

. , , 23 . , , , , , 71. .173 , , . , , , : ,   72. , , , , (Dio Cass. LIII. 31. 1). , 츭 . , , . , - . , , 23 . .

(Suet. Aug. 81. 1; Plin. NH. XIX. 38. 128; XXIX. 5. 6; Dio Cass. LIII. 30. 3). , - ; , , ; , , (εὐθὺς, Dio Cass. LIII. 32. 1) (Vell. Pat. II. 92. 1; Suet. Aug. 66. 6; Dio Cass. LIII. 32. 1, . Suet. Tib. 10. 1; Plin. NH. VII. 45. 149)73. - (Jos. Fl. AI. XV. 10. 2).

, 74. , 23 ., , , , 75, . .174 . , , ,   76. , 23 . ( , 18 . ), (, 30 29 . 26 24 .).

, 31 ., , . , . -, , , , . . , , , , (Dio Cass. LIII. 32. 34; CIL. VI. 2014). . (maius), , , (RGDA. 10; Suet. Aug. 27. 5; Dio Cass. LIII. 32. 56). : - 77.

, , , , , (Vell. Pat. II. 93. 1; Plin. NH. XXXVII. 5. 11; Dio Cass. LIII. 31. 23). , , , (παντὶ τῷ θέρει), (NH. XIX. 6. 24) , 1 , . . . .175 , , -, , 78. . , , -, , 79.

23 . , , . . , (Prop. III. 18. 720; Vell. Pat. II. 93. 1; Dio Cass. LIII. 30. 45; 33. 4). (Prop. III. 18. 7); , . , , , , , (Dio Cass. LIII. 30. 5)80. , . , ?

, , . , 23 . , , , . , , , , , 44 . . , . , 20- ., , auctoritas ( , , , , , ), , . 2623 . ୸ . , , , , , . 23 . .176 , ୸ . , : , auctoritas, ,   , , , , . , (Dio Cass. LIII. 30; 31. 4; Vell. Pat. II. 93). , ( ) , , , . , . , : , 81.

- . , , , , . , , , , . , 23 . . , 1020 .

. : , , , , . .177 , .

23 ., , , , . 23 . : , , , .

, , ,   , .

Tariverdieva S. E.
Marcellus in the Succession Policy of Augustus
(2921 B. C.)

The article deals with the events of 23 B. C. connected with the succession policy of Augustus. Ancient sources dont explain unanimously why during the twenties B. C. Augustus prepared to make Marcellus his heir but at the time of the crisis, when the problem of successor became actual, Marcellus vanished from sight and Agrippa came to the foreground. Modern researchers have offered different answers to this quesion and some of them have even argued that Augustus never planned to make Marcellus his successor. In the article this view is contested and a different explanation is proposed. The contradiction between Marcellus honours during the twenties B. C. and Augustus preference to Agrippa in 23 B. C. can be removed if Agrippa is viewed as a heir for the current moment and Marcellus as a heir in prospect. The article also deals with the problem how much the succession policy of Augustus was determined by blood relationship.


  • * . . . .
  • 1   . .
  • 2Syme R. The Roman Revolution. Oxford, 1939. P. 340346.
  • 3Brandt H. Marcellus successio praeparatus? Augustus, Marcellus und die Jahre 2923 v. Chr. // Chiron. 25. 1995. S. 117; Sawińsky P. Marcus Claudius Marcellus in the Octavian Augustus Family and Political Plans // Studia Lesco Mrozewicz ab amicis et discipulis dedicata / Ed. S. Rucińsky, C. Balbuza, C. Kŕólczyk. Poznán, 2011. P. 359367; Severy B. Augustus and the Family at the Birth of the Roman Empire. N. Y.; L., 2003. P. 6569.
  • 4Sawińsky P. Op. cit. P. 366.
  • 5Severy B. Op. cit. P. 6868.
  • 6., .: Gardthausen V. Augustus und seine Zeit. Leipzig, 1891. Tl. 1. Bd. 2. S. 720734; Fitzler K., Seek O. Julius (132) // RE. Hbd. 19. 1918. Sp. 339; 346347; . . . . .; ., 1949. . 537; Schmittenner W. Augustus spanischer Feldzug und der Kampf um den Prinzipat // Historia. Bd. 11. 1962. S. 6192; Williams G. Horace Odes I. 12 and the succession to Augustus // Hermathena. No. 118. 1974. P. 147155; Kienast D. Augustus: Prinzeps und Monarch. Darmstadt, 1992. S. 86, Anm. 70a; S. 87, 177.
  • 7Syme R. The Roman Revolution. P. 341, 346, 415416, 431; idem. The Augustan Aristocracy. Oxford, 1986. P. 83; Bauman R. A. Women and Politics in Ancient Rome. L.; N. Y., 1994. P. 100; Crook J. Political history, 30 B. C. to A. D. 14 // CAH. 2nd ed. Vol. X. Cambr., 1996. P. 8485; Bleicken J. Augustus. Eine Biographie. Hamburg, 2010. S. 339, 355.
  • 8Instinsky H. U. Augustus und die Adoption des Tiberius // Hermes. Bd. 94. 3. 1966. S. 336341; Roddaz J.-M. Marcus Agrippa. Rome, 1984. P. 307319.
  • 9Corbett J. H. The Succession Policy of Augustus // Latomus. T. 33. Fasc. 1. 1974. P. 8797. . . : . . . : . .; , 1994. . 279280.
  • 10Crook J. Op. cit. P. 83; Baroin C. Remembering ones Ancestors, Following in their Footsteps, being like them. The Role and Forms of Family Memory in the Building ofIdentity // Children, Memory & Family Identity in Roman Culture. Oxford, 2010. P. 1948
  • 11 , 27 . provincia , ୸ . . Syme R. The Roman Revolution. P. 313314. N. 1; Kienast D. Op. cit. S. 7475 + Anm. 2932; Crook J. Op. cit. P. 7879.
  • 12  . Fitzler K., Seek O. Op. cit. Sp. 338346; Syme R. The Roman Revolution. P. 313330; . . . . . 376394; Badian E. Crisis theories and the Beginning of the Principate // Romanitas  Christianitas. Untersuchungen zur Geschichte und Literatur der römischen Kaiserzeit. B.; N. Y., 1982. P. 2428; Kienast D. Op. cit. S. 6785; Crook J. Op. cit. P. 7384.
  • 13 auctoritas, ,  . : . . . . . 379401; . . . . . 5558 .
  • 14 (Lib. 66) (Fr. 21. 8), , (Mur. 11) , (potissimum) .
  • 15. Severy B. Op. cit. P. 4849.
  • 16 . : Southern P. Augustus. L.; N. Y., 1998. P. 108109.
  • 17 , , : Fitzler K., Seek O. Op. cit. Sp. 339.
  • 18Gaheis A. Claudius (230) // RE. Bd. III. 1899. Sp. 2765.
  • 19., .: Liv. XXI. 46. 710; Plut. Aem. 22. 38; Pomp. 3.
  • 20. : Gaheis A. Op. cit. Sp. 2765.
  • 21  .: Gesche H. Hat Caesar den Octavian zum Magister equitum designiert? // Historia. Bd. 22. Ht. 3. 1973. S. 468478.
  • 22 . .-. : Gardthausen V. Op. cit. S. 720; Roddaz J.-M. Op. cit. P. 310.
  • 23. Gardthausen V. Op. cit. S. 721; . . . ., 1990. . 129.
  • 24. : Prop. III. 18; Verg. Aen. VI. 860886.
  • 25 . . , , RGDA, , , , , ; , . . Westermann W. L. The Monument of Ancyra // AHR. Vol. 17. 1911. P. 111; Kienast D. Op. cit. S. 177.
  • 26Severy B. Op. cit. P. 6869; Brandt H. Op. cit. P. 34. . , (Anthol. Pal. 161; 545); .
  • 27Brandt H. Op. cit. P. 56.
  • 28Brandt H. Op. cit. P. 8.
  • 29Hor. Od. I. 12. 4548: Crescit occulto velut arbor aevo / fama Marcelli; micat inter omnis / Iulium sidus, velut inter ignis / luna minores. .: Williams G. Op. cit. P. 147155.
  • 30Brandt H. Op. cit. P. 13.
  • 31Roddaz J.-M. Op. cit. P. 311; Brandt H. Op. cit. P. 710; Severy B. Op. cit. P. 69. . , , , : Hanslik R. Vipsanius (2) // RE. R. 2. Hbd. 17. Sp. 1250.
  • 32 . . : Williams G. Op. cit. P. 152; Severy B. Op. cit. P. 70.
  • 33 . : Instinsky H. U. Op. cit. S. 336. . , (nur Platzhalter für einen Sohn aus dieser Ehe), : Bleicken J. Op. cit. S. 339.
  • 34Brandt H. Op. cit. P. 10.
  • 35 , , : Schmittenner W. Op. cit. S. 6192; Bleicken J. Op. cit. S. 339340. 23 . , (. ). 25 ., , . . . : Southern P. Op. cit. P. 119. . , - , , , : Gardthausen V. Op. cit. Tl. 1. Bd. 2. S. 722.
  • 36Brandt H. Op. cit. P. 13.
  • 37 .-. , , , : Roddaz J.-M. Op. cit. P. 316
  • 38Sawińsky P. Op. cit. P. 361.
  • 39Münzer F. Claudii Marcelli // RE. Bd. III. 1899. Sp. 27312732.
  • 40. , : Instinsky H. U. Op. cit. S. 335336
  • 41Brandt H. Op. cit. P. 11.
  • 42. Crook J. Op. cit. P. 7677; 14- : , ( ), , , 20 (Dio Cass. LV. 9. 2).
  • 43 , , , , . . , . . . . . . 255
  • 44Sawińsky P. Op. cit. P. 365.
  • 45Brandt H. Op. cit. S. 89.
  • 46Burnett A., Amandry M., Ripolles P. P. Roman Provincial Coinage. Vol. I: From the Death of Caesar to the Death of Vitellius (44 BCAD 69). Part I. L., 1992. P. 716. Nr. 5415.
  • 47Brandt H. Op. cit. S. 9. Anm. 45.
  • 48Grant M. From Imperium to Auctoritas. Cambr., 1946. P. 8182 ( , ); idem. Roman Imperial Money. Edinburgh, 1954. P. 2728. . : Sutherland C. H. V. Coinage in Roman Imperial Policy 31 BCAD 68. L., 1951. P. 55; idem. Roman history and coinage 44 BCAD 69. Oxford, 1987, P. 2425. . . : Kienast D. Op. cit. S. 91. Anm. 97; Williams G. Op. cit. P. 150151.
  • 49  . Burnett A. et al. Op. cit. P. 716. Nr. 5415.
  • 50 , .: Sutherland C. H. V. Roman Imperial Coinage. Vol. 1. From 31 B. C. to A. D. 69. L., 1984. P. 3134.
  • 51Brandt H. Op. cit. S. 9.
  • 52. , , : Williams G. Op. cit. P. 151.
  • 53Grant M. From Imperium to Auctoritas. P. 81; idem. Roman Imperial Money. P. 28; Sutherland C. H. V. Coinage in Roman Imperial Policy P. 55.
  • 54Roddaz J.-M. Op. cit. P. 593612.
  • 55Mattingly H. B. Roman coins from the earliest times to the fall of the Western Empire. L., 1927. P. 7475.
  • 56Fittschen K., Zanker P. Katalog der römischen Porträts in den Capitolinischen Museen der Stadt Rom. Vol. I. Mainz, 1985. Nr. 19 (non vidi); Brandt H. Op. cit. S. 15 + Anm. 75.
  • 57Balty Ch. Notes diconographie julio-claudienne IV: M. Claudius Marcellus et le type 13 de liconographie d Auguste jeune // Antike Kunst. Bd. 20. 1977. S. 106, 112115, c . ,   .
  • 58Balty Ch. Op. cit. P. 102118; Andreae B. Noch einmal zum Octaviansporträt Typus B // Ritratto ufficiale e ritratto privato. Roma, 1988, S. 113118 (non vidi); Rosso E. LImage de lempereur en Gaule Romaine. Portraits et inscriptions. P., 2006. P. 322325 .
  • 59Brandt H. Op. cit. S. 15.
  • 60Roddaz J.-M. Op. cit. P. 316318
  • 61. . : . . . . . 280.
  • 62. Dio Cass. LX. 33. 2. 2; Gai. I. 61; Instinsky H. U. Op. cit. S. 326327.
  • 63 : Magie D. The Mission of Agrippa to the Orient in 23 B. C. // CPh. Vol. 3. No. 2. 1908. P. 145146; Crook J. Op. cit. P. 85.
  • 64Vell. Pat. II. 93; Plin. NH. VII. 45. 149; Tac. Ann. XIV. 53. 3; Suet. Aug. 66. 3; Tib. 10. 12; Dio Cass. LIII. 32. 1.
  • 65 : M. Marcellus, sororis Augusti Octaviae filius, quem homines ita, si quid accidisset Caesari, successorem potentiae eius arbitrabantur futurum, ut tamen id per M. Agrippam securo ei posse contingere non existimarent, magnificentissimo munere aedilitatis edito decessit ( . , , . : , , , . . . . ). , , . 23 ., , , , 渭 . , , .
  • 66Swan M. The Consular Fasti of 23 B. C. and the conspiracy of Varro Murena // HSCPh. Vol. 71. 1966. P. 240241. , , (. 240242) 23 ( 22 ., (LIV. 3)); . Sumner G. V. Varrones Murenae // HSCPh. Vol. 82. 1978. P. 191195; Badian E. Op. cit. P. 1841. 22 .  .: Kienast D. Op. cit. S. 86. Anm. 72.
  • 67Ps.-Caes. Afr. 3. 1; 18. 1; Crawford M. Roman Republican Coinage. Cambr., 1974. No. 446.
  • 68Bleicken J. Op. cit. P. 348349.
  • 69., : Roddaz J.-M. Op. cit. P. 312319; Simpson C. J. Romes Official Imperial Seal? The Rings of Augustus and His First Century Successors // Historia. Bd. 54. 2. 2005. P. 180188, .
  • 70. . , , : Bauman R. A. Op. cit. P. 101. , , , .
  • 71Brandt H. Op. cit. P. 12.
  • 72Dio Cass. LIII. 30. 2: Μάρκελλον πάντων προκριθήσεσθαι; Vell. Pat. II. 93. 1: quem homines ita, si quid accidisset Caesari, successorem potentiae eius arbitrabantur futurum.
  • 73.-. , , , 23 .: Roddaz J.-M. Op. cit. P. 325.
  • 74., .: Syme R. The Roman Revolution. P. 337; Kienast D. Op. cit. S. 90; Crook J. Op. cit. P. 87.
  • 75 23 . , , maius. ,  . Syme R. The Roman Revolution. P. 337; Hanslik R. Op. cit. Sp. 12511251; Roddaz J.-M. Op. cit. P. 339351; Kienast D. Op. cit. S. 9192; Crook J. Op. cit. P. 8485.
  • 76. Hanslik R. Op. cit. Sp. 1252 ( , (Beseitigung) ); Crook J. Op. cit. P. 85. . , , ( ) , 25 .: Williams G. Op. cit. P. 152. ; , .
  • 77 23 . . : Fitzler K., Seek O. Op. cit. Sp. 347348; Syme R. The Roman Revolution. P. 33338; . . . . . 394400; Badian E. Op. cit. P. 3135; Kienast D. Op. cit. S. 8890; Crook J. Op. cit. P. 8587.
  • 78Prop. III. 18. 1920; . Dio Cass. LIII. 30. 5; Badian E. Op. cit. P. 2223 + n. 13.
  • 79Richardson J. S. Augustan Rome. 44 B. C. to A. D. 14. Edinburgh, 2012. P. 102.
  • 80  .: Gaheis A. Op. cit. Sp. 2768.
  • 81. . , 23 . ( . . . . . 255). , , , 2523 . .
  • 1407695006 1407695008 1407695015 1421062316 1421232552 1421232708

    , .